Subscribe to the daily newsletter.

Neville vows to learn from criticism of “monotone” England commentary


Philip Neville has said that criticism of his commentary during England’s World Cup defeat to Italy on Saturday night will only “make me better”.

The former Manchester United and Everton star was panned on social networking sites for what was deemed to be his “monotone” speaking voice.

On Twitter, his soporific contributions were compared to the computer HAL-9000 from 2001: A Space Odyssey, a robot and a “Dignitas satnav”.

Yesterday, Neville responded by saying he would “take” the criticism while admitting the high-profile occasion was his first ever live co-commentary for the BBC.

In response to the reaction to Neville’s commentary, the BBC said he remained an “important, well respected” member of its World Cup team.

A spokesman said: “Phil is an important, well respected member of our team and will continue to play a key role throughout the tournament, both as a studio guest and match commentator.”

However, Neville could be dropped for the BBC’s next scheduled live broadcast of an England game, which would be in the last 16 if Roy Hodgson’s men make it through their group.

The spokesman added: “Everything for the final 16 will be decided much closer to the time.”

Neville is due to be a studio pundit for Iran v Nigeria today, Russia v South Korea tomorrow and Nigeria v Bosnia on Saturday.

He will also co-commentate the highlights of both England v Uruguay on Thursday and the clash with Costa Rica on Tuesday 24th.

Some of the Twitter reaction to Neville’s commentary is below:

Related News